Monday, July 23, 2012

Pretentious About the Subjective

After searching for a new job, I think I've come across the perfect low-stress job that perfectly plays into my skills as a professional shoveler of nonsense and smug superiority, a sommelier. For those who don't know, a sommelier is a person who snobbishly proclaims to know which wines from what year taste the best and what wine pairs with what food. In other words they take something subjective, like taste, and try to attribute an empirical knowledge to it. Or to simplify it even more, they're well-paid winos. 

The only real skill is to master the language. "Oh an '87 Pinot from the Rhone region of France with earthy tones and notes of cocoa will unlock the savory smokiness of the filet while preparing your palette for an onslaught of flavor the likes of which elude the greatest of this world's poets, transporting you through the ethereal miasma unto a new plane of understanding. Please, sniff the glass first. We taste with all our senses."
Saying it like that sounds a lot better than, "I dunno, the meat is red, go with a red one." 

Not to de-mistify the profession, but there have been studies where they put leading wine "experts" and had a taste test, asking them to choose blindly which tasted better. When they knew the price, they chose the more expensive kind, but without any knowledge, going into it blind, they chose the cheap stuff, but even more telling, there was no overlap in their ranking. 

It's like asking a group of Feng Shui experts to decide the singular source of your home's chi. Or like asking a group of porn stars the optimum sexual position for pleasure.

Sometimes, because you do something a lot, you are better at it than the average person (like blogging, uh thank you), but you certainly can't tell someone else how to best enjoy themselves. There are some things we can't know. How other people experience things is one of them. 

Sommeliers and Cigar Aficionados have a lot in common. Both are smugly superior about cancer-inducing habits that are purely subjective. Perhaps if I was more interested in spending my time cultivating fake "knowledge" of something that's completely non-quantifiable, perhaps I too could be a "foodie" or movie aficionado. 

Yeah, he's fun to hang out with. I bet his porn is Food and Wine magazine. Source
You know what's missing, the void I can fill? Chip sommelier (Crisp aficionado if you're in the UK).
I mean, that's the life. You can be called an expert without really having to prove it with empirical evidence. 

"To best take the oral journey of that ham sandwich I recommend the sea salt and vinegar ruffled potato chip from the Milwaukee region preferably made from the potatoes harvested in May as the rain which fell in March and April helped grow a blend organically baked with spices that were cross-pollinated during that time and the master bakers were all suffering from massive depression which caused them to infuse the chips with their beer burps giving it a malty flavor and bringing out the honey notes of the ham blending it effortlessly with the Swiss cheese and deli mustard."

If you'll excuse me, I need to now go eat a ham sandwich and cram fist fulls of chips in my word hole, you know, for practice.

22 comments:

  1. Say what you want, but I have perfected the art of wine tasting. No amount of your studies and science can disprove my superior palette.

    Take this vintage '96 Valpolicella I have on my desk. Mmm, I'm getting earth, I'm getting unwashed Italian soles, I'm getting luggage, kumquats, and hedgehog tears. I'm getting paid far too much for this nonsense.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hmm ... this wine is ... amusing ... but not quite ... hysterical. Nutty, but ... not quite crazy.

    You bring up some valid points and do so in a consistently funny (but not quite loony) manner.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You missed out the word "mignon". But your Crisp Aficionado sounded good. You could do that one easy. I think it's generally thought that the more expensive a wine is, the better it tastes. What makes this even more bizarre though is that the more expensive a wine is, the more you MUST NOT drink it. So you really are better off sticking to the cheap stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am a music snob, so I pretty much exceed at claiming I can objectively weigh the subjective.

    I think your wine idea is great, and I might have to try it. I'd come home late again, drunk, and when my wife says something, I can point to my bloodshot eyes and say, "You see how hard I've been working? I bet I drank 100 glasses of wine today!"

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hahahh Boyfriend has mentioned that study to me a few times too. Not like a need an excuse to only buy less than $10 bottles of wine, but its good to know. :P

    ReplyDelete
  6. I'd like to be a Whiskey Sommelier or a Joint Aficionado, are those paying gigs?

    ReplyDelete
  7. My girlfriend calls me the TP sommalier. When she goes shopping, she buys whatever is on sale. Me? I explain why A is better than B, and get detailed.

    It's not a glamorous position, but when your finger breaks through 'the barrier' when you're wiping, you will wish you had consulted with me...

    ReplyDelete
  8. I feel this exact way about people who are music snobs. Umm, hi, everyone likes different music and that's okay. Every time someone is snobby about music I want to blast "I'm Allright" by Kenny Loggins and yell, "That's my jam bitches!!!"

    ReplyDelete
  9. I have long suspected that pretentious snobs are people with self-esteem issues. I do love a good crisp though. You guys have these Mikesells crisps that are bacon flavored. Whoever created those was one stoned out genius. Nectar of the gods I'm telling you.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I buy wine based on how pretty the label is :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am a total wino. I'm quite pretentious about the wine I'll drink. I find it funny. I don't judge others tastes though. The thing my last Roommate always said was that she liked doing wine tastings with me, because I could help her identify the things she likes in a wine, and the things she doesn't, and that would help her figure out other wines she does like. To each their own.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This makes me want to drink cheap wine and eat some Pringles... together. Which wine do you recommend to pair with a 2012 Salt & Vinegar Pringle?

    ReplyDelete
  13. So very true. I, myself, was an expert while abroad for a few years in Germany and went wine tasting every weekend. I wasn't snobbish though - I was just trashed and everything was delicious!

    ReplyDelete
  14. My fav kind of sandwich is cheese, mustard and potato chips. I'm screwed on this one. I need a fancier sandwich.

    Hugs!

    Valerie

    ReplyDelete
  15. I love me a good sandwich, especially if somebody else makes it. I'm an expert on sandwiches.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Wine is stupid. It leads to babies, and nobody wants that. Parents say they like babies, or at least their own, but that's crap, and we all know it. On the other hand, we all love crisps. I made out with all of the UK, so I call chips crisps. The ham sandwich would have been better paired with a sea salt and cracked pepper baked crisp.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I know that drawing. I remember that drawing. You did that for me. Ages ago and I still love it.
    I am no wine snob though (although I do know a good peppery shiraz when I taste one)

    ReplyDelete
  18. If you need a tasting assistant, hit me up.

    ReplyDelete
  19. RCB's favorite line of the day: 'they take something subjective, like taste, and try to attribute an empirical knowledge to it.'Hahaha. Ever seen Bottle shock? The French are funny people, alright. By the way, politicians would make great sommeliers... Then again, they don't fill the void - they are the void.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Imaginary Pickleope speaking: You're always right when you say I'm right.

      Delete
  20. Ugh, any job where I don't have to wrestle a gigantic machine into submission for 12 hours at a time would be lovely.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I refer to everything as having a hint of smoked cheddar and a slight kerosene aftertaste. Which slightly upsets my wife after we share a passionate kiss.

    ReplyDelete

ShareThis